Annie's Frozen Custard Info
Amenities
Service options
-
Takeout
Accessibility
-
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Payments
-
Credit cards
Best KPortal Reviews
The taste of the flavors is pretty good but you get a very little amount of ice cream for the price. Paid almost the same price for six ice creams here as six full meals across the street.
Such a cute little place. The cashier was brand new and bless her heart she seemed beyond overwhelmed. She got our orders perfect though! The custard was stellar, do yourself a favor and stop here.
Great custard ice cream! Amazing service! Thank you!
The custard was really yummy, but more than half their menu was unavailable. They also gave our food to someone else so we had to wait twice as long—and it was a long wait even without the extra. When the food did come out it was really tasty and we enjoyed it. It’s also a new restaurant so they may still be figuring things out and the staff was friendly.
TLDR; food was good, it took to long to be made, staff was friendly, but they didn’t have several dishes we desired.
So disappointed, will not return. This place was awesome before the pandemic. They have since remodeled and got rid of the napkin fan art that would make stopping by worthwhile so don't come looking for it. As for the experience itself, it took over 20 minutes to get our four simple cups served to us and there weren't even any other customers in the shop. The reason for the delay is (prepare yourself, I'm not even kidding) they literally use a scale and will measure and adjust whatever is on your cone or cup as many times as necessary so that you get the EXACT amount they want to give you. The stingy vibe was a total turn off, and it felt weird to see someone taking ice cream OUT of my bowl before it was given to me 'ere they give me a quarter ounce more, heaven forbid. Not to mention that by the time they've quadruple checked that they gave you the right amount, your custard is half melted. The flavors are good but they do not justify the price or the penny-pinching vibe!!! The audacity to charge the amount they do for the tiny, over-measured scoops they give is just astonishing. My honest advice? Save yourself the disappointment and go to the red restaurant across the street to get an ice cream brick instead; even with the crazy long lines you'll probably get your treat faster, and the prices and amounts are way more reasonable.
This salad is amazing! Such amazing flavors! Pure yumminess!
The custard was good, but nothing else about this experience was up to standard. The $6 worth of custard was tiny. One scoop meant literally a scoop. And nothing on the menu was available except the custard. The waffles weren’t available, pot pie wasn’t available, the Mac and cheese wasn’t available, the salads weren’t available. Seriously, we just bought the custard to have something to eat.
Been here hundreds of times over the years. This week we went for the first time this year. What an extreme disappointment. Nobody seemed to care, lots of items were not available, frozen custard was only okay. Portions were about 1/3 of what they used to be with higher prices. For sure will not return. I’m sure they must have new owners who just want to fleece the tourists and don’t really care. So so sad as this was always a highlight of Nauvoo in the summer.
Quick Facts About Annie's Frozen Custard
Today
Opening Hours
| Monday | 11:30 AM - 11:30 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM - 11:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM - 11:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM - 11:30 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM - 11:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM - 11:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
How to go there
Location
Places